Bermuda or Bahamas

I have been having an urge to book another vacation. I had looked into the Bahamas last month, but it was pretty pricey. I am now insanely jealous of my co-worker who is heading there this Friday, and got an amazing deal. Hmmm I have to pick an island to get certified to scuba dive, just may have to do this and if I do, here is where I would stay...
Atlantis
One and Only Resort
Pink Sands

I've also heard great things about Bermuda... just a short flight from NYC.
Rosewood Tuckers Point

The Reefs

Now... need to find someone to come with!! A long weekend away can't come soon enough!